Etched into the glass panels of the Parliament Hill memorial known as the Honour Roll are the names of the more than 880 Canadian police and peace officers who have died in the line of duty since Confederation.
The widow of an Ontario Provincial Police officer who took his own life and a former Ottawa police staff sergeant want that to change.
“He is a hero in life and in death, and he should be acknowledged and recognized equally as anyone else, any other fallen officer who died in the line of duty,” said his widow, Loan de Bock.
“His death was a result of his mental decline, and it was a cumulative toll of police work. And because of that, I believe he deserves to be up there [on the wall].”
She submitted an application to the national memorial in March to have his name engraved on the wall. The application was accompanied by a letter of support by then Interim OPP Commissioner Gary Couture, saying he believed de Bock’s death the result of mental illness acquired in the line of duty, and a letter from his doctor stating the same.
The Canadian Police Association sent back a request for more information, including whether his illness was recognized by Ontario’s Workplace Safety and Insurance Board and if he had been diagnosed with a mental health condition at the time of his death.
She called it “insulting” that families are being asked to provide more information, proof, that their loved ones died in the line of duty and mental health issues aren’t given the same consideration as physical injuries.
Syd Gravel agrees.
Gravel was part of the transition team in the 1990s when Ottawa police handed stewardship of the memorial over to the Canadian Police Association. At the time, Gravel said, the idea of including the names of officers who had taken their own lives was raised.
“Essentially, it was a very sensitive issue for some of the families to accept that someone that died by suicide would be recognized as a line of death duty. The family members made it clear to us as an organizing committee that they weren’t comfortable with us including those names at that time,” he said.
“When we look at people who die by suicide, the perspective is that … it’s not seen by some as being that death that came about as a result of wearing the uniform, and I think that’s the link that’s lacking,” he said.
“People are still not getting that wearing a uniform, seeing over 600 to 900 traumatic events in a career, can potentially be more than anybody can handle.”
The Ottawa Police Service’s own memorial website lists the names of 14 officers who died in the line of duty between 1929 and 2009, but does not include two officers who took their lives in the past five years, including one who died last week on the eve of the annual memorial weekend for fallen officers on Parliament Hill.
Det. Thomas Roberts, 35, died by suicide at Ottawa police headquarters on Elgin Street on Sept. 27, the eve of a weekend dedicated to the memory of fallen officers. (Ottawa police ) Issue being discussed
In a statement to CBC News, the Ottawa Police Service wrote: “Suicides are not considered incidents where an officer was killed in the line of duty.”
In August 2018, Toronto police began accepting applications for members who have “lost their lives because of mental health injuries” for the service’s Memorial Wall after reaching a settlement with the Ontario Human Rights Commission.
CBC News contacted the organizations responsible for deciding which fallen officers are added to the Honour Roll. The Canadian Police Association, Canadian Association of Chiefs of Police (CACP) and Canadian Peace Officers Memorial Association all declined an interview.
The CACP and the CPA would only say the issue is part of an ongoing discussion.
Terry Welsh, co-ordinator of the Canadian Memorial Service, confirmed to CBC News that no officer who has died by suicide has ever been included on the Honour Roll. Welsh said one application was received in the past couple years, but was sent back to the police service’s chief for more information. He did not name the police force.
‘I’m intensely heartbroken’
To qualify currently, the officer must have been on duty at the time of their death, or, if off duty, must have “died as a result of an external influence.”
However, the rules also seem to leave the door open, stating: “Notwithstanding the above, any set of circumstances which led to the death of an officer, may be considered.”
“I’m intensely heartbroken every time we lose a member, and I’m intensely heartbroken, knowing full well that it’s going to be discussed one more time to see if they can get their names on the wall on Parliament Hill because they did die, in my opinion, in the line of duty,” he said.
“We just have to continue to persevere to make sure that the names and legacy of our loved ones is not forgotten and that it is recognized.”