Columnist Amy Dickinson (Bill Hogan/Chicago Tribune)
Most recently, they also decided against continuing to financially support me.
What should I do with my life?
Ask Amy: She blasted me about Facebook posts that didn’t concern her
Ask Amy: These hikers made me uncomfortable. Should I have said something?
Ask Amy: My boyfriend disappeared into the ugliness of 4chan
DEAR PROSPECTIVE: No, your parents should not provide you with a comfortable living while you get your act together. You’re on your own now. And this is what it feels like to be on our own (hint: often, it feels vexingly uncomfortable).
Law school might not be for you. For one thing, your own judgment and critical-thinking skills seem so faulty that you just don’t seem cut out for a career in the law (although your gas-lighting skills would probably acquit you nicely).
Acting, however, will allow you to inhabit fantasy and express your creativity. Acting is deep and hard work, however — and opportunities don’t present themselves unless and until you are ready to recognize and accept them.
DEAR AMY: My great-niece is 11 years old. I’m very concerned about her.
I asked my brother how my great-niece is handling this and he said, “Not very good.” He asked me for any advice. I told him that I wasn’t sure how to handle this.
My concern is that she stays in her bedroom all the time and seems very withdrawn, depressed and unhappy. She used to be happy and smiling. Any help on how to handle this very difficult situation?
DEAR WORRIED: Now is the time to surround this girl with love, affection and attention. You can probably imagine how conflicted and hurt she is feeling — her mother, who abandoned her, is now starting another family. This will revive every abandonment sadness she has ever had, and will likely introduce more feelings that she can’t articulate and doesn’t know how to handle.
Her guardians should not let her isolate herself. Privacy is important for young adolescents, but isolation will contribute to her sadness.
Everyone in the family should attempt to talk to her about this. Don’t assume she is happy about this news, and don’t force her toward a happy narrative (“Hey — you’re going to have a little sister!”). Instead, ask her, “Can you describe how you are feeling?” If she is inarticulate or silent, don’t correct her. Reassure her and enfold her in her family’s embrace. Watch a favorite movie together. Go bowling and ice-skating. Put her first.
Books will help her to process and tackle some of her sadness and worry. Give her some good, age-appropriate books to dive into (I highly recommend the site amightygirl.com for book suggestions). Read together.
A book for the adults to consider is: “The Worry Workbook for Kids: Helping Children to Overcome Anxiety and the Fear of Uncertainty (An Instant Help Book for Parents Kids),” by Muniya S. Khanna and Deborah Roth (2018, Instant Help).
If it’s possible, she should also see a counselor with experience in working with children. An independent, caring and supportive adult could coach her in ways to process and respond to her very big feelings.
Want Ask Amy delivered to your inbox for free on weekdays?
Correcting the Correction
DEAR CORRECTING: The beautiful thing about this is that I’ve heard from several hundred people who are deeply engaged and knowledgeable about both horses and language. My understanding is that both spellings are used. Thank you all.
Julie Jason: Readers write about 401(k)s
Miss Manners: Florida visitor doesn’t want to be stuck inside
You can contact Amy Dickinson via email: ASKAMY@amydickinson.com. Readers may send postal mail to Ask Amy, P.O. Box 194, Freeville, NY 13068. You can also follow her on Twitter @askingamy or “like” her on Facebook.